OSPREY BLOGS
Ruth

Is this beauty just in the eye of the beholder?

June 22, 2007 12:00 AM
Close

To proceed please login below or register.

Email:
Password:
COMMENTS
Archive Comments
15-Jul-2008 10:17

I think you've convincingly demonstrated that they can be. Cool pics!

Posted by: Marc Nelson Jr. | June 23, 2007 at 12:07 AM

Report this comment

Archive Comments
15-Jul-2008 10:18

I guess they can be filed under "Lethal Beauty" ;)

Posted by: Roys | June 25, 2007 at 03:33 AM

Report this comment

Archive Comments
15-Jul-2008 10:18

I remember touring the Somme one October and wondering why the local farmers had piled up waist high heaps of neatly stacked logs next to their fields. They were shells, of course!

Posted by: Simon Fielding | June 27, 2007 at 01:51 PM

Report this comment

Archive Comments
15-Jul-2008 10:18

In some cases what you may be seeing is a "pride of maker/pride of owner" especially in older and custom pieces. Samurai armour, for example, often looks beautiful for several reasons: because the pieces that have survived 1)were preserved Because they look good, 2) were originally made as "dress armour" in a relatively peaceful period (anything after about 1600) 3) males are peacocks and they like to look good. (Women are just as bad guys, don't worry about it.)

Various fortifications, in a similar vein, often look good/interesting because in order to be effective, they need to allow for certain fields of fire for offence and defense. This follows mathematic formulas. If you've seen or read anything of Da Vinci for example, you know that often the application of math formulas to a structure will give it an appearance that we process as being asthetically pleasing.

So no, your observation makes sense to me. I could probably write a whole article on this subject.

Posted by: Jen Hall | September 04, 2007 at 11:08 AM

Report this comment

Archive Comments
15-Jul-2008 10:18

I agree that many artefacts which have been preserved have been so because they were prized by previous generations, often not because of their original use but because of their appearance/value. Thus, we end up with the beautiful, the significant and also the 'surprisingly well-survived item of use' of yesteryear, making it easy to illustrate books on ancient, medieval, and often oriental topics with luscious images! :0)
As for the rest, maths probably is the answer to the pleasing appearance of more recent military forts/hardware. I always think aerial views of castles and forts are pretty interesting. Particularly because when they were built that viewpoint was never considered, or even possible, so when you see something like that, it's sort of like being let in on a secret, or finding a hidden path/door - a pleasing sensation for a nosy picture editor!

Posted by: Ruth | September 04, 2007 at 05:33 PM

Report this comment